Peter's Polar Parlor: Delight in Irresistible Ice Cream Treats and Seasonal Flavors

It was a trip down memory lane…. Pete’s polar parlor was the new ice cream place when I first started playing baseball in 2nd grade with the Onondaga Chiefs. We want after a game and it was awesome! Well Pete’s is still there and I’m 65! ( it has changed owners a couple of times). The ice cream is good, a little on the expensive side. And there are a lot of choices. if you are looking for a deal move on. They have lots of choices and some outside seating spread around. The day I returned it was a beautiful day and the line was long which is expected in CNY

Great ice cream. Love the huge variety. The staff are all very friendly (even if they are teenagers as you point out as excuses in all of your comments to other reviews). The bees are a huge issue and get worse each time I’m there. They are inside and outside of the building. The staff shouldn’t have to work with so many bees flying around them. Customers can’t even sit outside to enjoy their ice cream. Everyone was getting up to leave because they were so bad. This really needs to be taken care of.

5 Stars for Pete’s Polar Parlor – The Best Ice Cream Around! Pete’s Polar Parlor is hands down the best ice cream spot in town! From the moment you walk in, the fun, nostalgic vibe and friendly staff make you feel right at home. But the real star here is the ice cream—creamy, rich, and packed with flavor. I’ve tried so many of their flavors, and each one is absolutely delicious. The chocolate vanilla soft serve is decadent, dole parfaits are refreshingly perfect, and their seasonal specials never disappoint. The portions are generous, and the waffle cones are always fresh and crispy. What really sets Pete’s apart is their commitment to quality and creativity. Whether you’re a classic vanilla lover or an adventurous flavor seeker, they’ve got something for everyone. Plus, their service is always fast and cheerful, even on the busiest days. If you haven’t visited Pete’s Polar Parlor yet, you’re missing out! This place is a must-visit for ice cream fans. Five stars all the way—I’ll be back again and again! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

We're ice cream lovers- we've been to almost every stand in the greater Syracuse area, and even more across NYS in general. Pete's is not the cheapest. HOWEVER. Pete's polar parlor is great quality. Personally, we'd rather have good quality ice cream with a large variety of fun and unique items, vs a big serving of mediocre ice cream for cheap. Their homemade custard is amazing. The pumpkin and maple is out favorite during fall time, but the flavours they do in the summer are great too. They also have incredible sundaes. They're a big size and a fair price with delicious toppings. The baked items included (brownies, pie, ECT) are all miles above in quality compared to other ice cream stands. We also find that the employees are all really kind and friendly. They have no problem answering questions or making suggestions. :)

Ice cream was amazing and service couldn't be beat. You could tell the staff loved their job!

Had a Sunday with the maple pecan ice cream. Loved it! Place has great ambiance. Outdoor dining only and very popular with the locals. If you're in the area, it's worth a stop.

Like most of my ice cream reviews, your personal experience will hinge upon whether or not you like ice cream. If you do, guaranteed 5 stars, if not, I'm confused why you are reading reviews...anywho. It's a nice ice cream stand with standard prices, plenty of options to choose from and happy faces all around. Service was quick and smooth. Enjoy!!

The place is great for families and kids. Their products are excellent, especially their mix of contrasts: sweet and sour, salty and sweet. It's something wonderful to enjoy during the beautiful summer days.